Use Lucide first if Heroicons feels too small, then check Tabler, Phosphor, Remix, and Radix. Heroicons is still a clean MIT licensed SVG set from Tailwind Labs, and it works very well with Tailwind projects [source: GitHub]. But teams often need more styles, more icons, or tighter React control.
TLDR: Pick Lucide for a safe all rounder. Pick Tabler Icons when you need a huge set. For example, if your SaaS dashboard has 120 icon spots and Heroicons misses 15% of them, your team may lose hours making one-off icons. That is how design systems get messy fast.
Why even replace Heroicons?
Heroicons is lovely. It is simple. It is tidy. It fits Tailwind like a sock fits a foot.
Still, real products grow. A settings page needs strange icons. A billing page needs payment icons. A user table needs tiny action icons. Then someone grabs a random SVG from the internet. It drives me a little wild when one missing icon adds 12 minutes of cleanup.
A good icon set should give you:
- SVG files that are easy to edit.
- React components that are easy to import.
- Style choices like outline, fill, duotone, or bold.
- Clear naming so developers do not guess.
- A consistent look across the whole app.
1. Lucide
Best for: clean SaaS apps, admin panels, dashboards, and React teams.
Lucide is a community fork of Feather Icons. It keeps that thin, calm, line icon style. It also adds many more icons. The React package is simple, and icons can be styled with props like size, color, and stroke width [source: Lucide].
Use it when you want something close to Heroicons, but with more range. It feels friendly. It does not shout. It sits nicely in buttons, sidebars, cards, and empty states.
Small gripe: Some icons can feel too light at 16px. You may need to bump the stroke width a bit.
2. Tabler Icons
Best for: large products with lots of screens.
Tabler Icons is huge. That is the whole charm. It has icons for common UI actions, commerce, files, maps, charts, health, devices, and more. If your app has many features, Tabler can save you from icon hunting.
The set uses a clean outline style. It works well in React. It also gives your product a clear visual rhythm when used with the same size and stroke.
Honestly, it feels like the icon drawer you wish every design tool had by default. Search, pick, ship. Done.
Good fit: CRM tools, analytics products, internal tools, and big admin apps.
3. Phosphor Icons
Best for: products that need mood and variety.
Phosphor Icons has a nice trick. Many icons come in several weights. Thin. Light. Regular. Bold. Fill. Duotone. That makes it more flexible than many plain outline sets.
This is great for product design. You can use regular icons in nav items. Use filled icons for active states. Use duotone icons in onboarding screens. The app still feels connected because the shapes share one family style.
Phosphor is a strong pick for apps that want a little warmth. It feels less strict than Heroicons. It can make empty states and help screens feel less cold.
Watch out: Too many weights can cause chaos. Set rules early. For example, use regular for default and fill for selected.
4. Remix Icon
Best for: balanced apps that need both line and filled icons.
Remix Icon gives you a broad icon set with a modern feel. Most icons come in line and fill versions. That is very useful for React interfaces.
Why? Because UI states matter. A filled home icon can show the current page. A line home icon can show an inactive page. Users understand that without reading anything.
Remix works well for mobile apps, web apps, and marketing pages. The style is simple enough for serious software, but not dull.
The annoying part: Naming can take a moment to learn. You may search “user” and then try “account” or “profile” before finding the exact match.
5. Radix Icons
Best for: small UI controls and crisp interface details.
Radix Icons is smaller than the others. That is not a bad thing. It is focused. It feels made for real interface parts, not giant icon posters.
The icons are clean at small sizes. They pair well with buttons, menus, dialogs, inputs, and toolbar actions. If you already use Radix UI, the icons feel like a natural match.
Use Radix when your product needs quiet, precise icons. It is not the best pick for huge marketing pages. It is very good for compact React components.
How to choose without making a mess
Do not mix five icon sets in one app. That way lies visual soup.
Pick one main set. Then write a few rules:
- Size: Use 16px, 20px, or 24px. Avoid random sizes.
- Stroke: Keep one stroke width for outline icons.
- States: Use fill only for selected or active items.
- Color: Use design tokens, not random hex codes.
- Names: Wrap icons in your own component if needed.
A simple React wrapper can help a lot. It can set default size, stroke, color, and accessibility labels. Then every icon behaves the same way. Designers relax. Developers stop guessing. Users see a cleaner product.
Quick picks
- Choose Lucide if you want the safest Heroicons replacement.
- Choose Tabler if your product needs tons of icons.
- Choose Phosphor if you want several weights and more personality.
- Choose Remix if you need line and fill pairs.
- Choose Radix if you care about tiny, crisp UI controls.
Final pick? Start with Lucide for most React apps. Move to Tabler when scale matters. Use Phosphor when the brand needs more charm. Keep it simple. Your interface will thank you.
